Arguments Against Hunting Trophies
For supporters of animal rights, hunting for trophies is one of the worst kinds of violations. The animal rights viewpoint starts with the premise that animals deserve to live out their natural lifespan just like humans. From that standpoint, killing any animal for sport is morally offensive: It deprives animals of their right to life, and their deaths serve no justifiable purpose. The offense is compounded when some of the animals killed by trophy hunters are from rare or endangered species.
Some methods of obtaining exotic or outsized trophies are far from sportsmanlike. Proponents of ethical hunting and animal welfare both condemn the practice of canned hunting -- breeding animals in captivity to be killed by hunters in enclosed spaces. South Africa is one of several countries that have banned the practice, but it still continues [source: Environmental News Service]. Practices like canned hunting are considered by some as abuse of wildlife.
Some scientists say that systematically hunting the most mature members of an animal population can adversely affect its gene pool. This will reduce the average size of future generations and threaten the ability of the species to thrive in its habitat. Researchers claim repeated hunting over many years has gradually diminished the size of the Kodiak bears of Alaska. Furthermore, hunting has altered the bears' behavior in a cause-and-effect manner. Because the bears have grown so frightened of humans, they are more likely to forego their normal salmon runs, thus undermining their own nutrition and health. Killing off the adult males of any species may decrease the survival odds of the surviving young. It may also destabilize the population by creating a shortage of males. If females are also targeted, hunting can mean the loss of the survival knowledge that mother bears pass on to their offspring [source: Nilsson].
Despite the arguments, trophy hunting is sure to continue around the world. How do you feel about it? Is trophy hunting good, bad or somewhere in the middle? Now that you have the facts, you can join in on the debate that is sure to continue for generations to come.
Related HowStuffWorks Articles
More Great Links
- African Sky. " Hunting the Big Five, Hunt with African Sky." (Accessed 11/24/08)http://www.africanskyhunting.co.za/hunting-big-five.html
- African Trophy. "Hunting Safaris." (Accessed 11/24/08)http://www.africantrophy.com/safari.html
- African Trophy. "Trophies, Horns & Hides." (Accessed 11/24/08)http://www.africantrophy.com/trophies.html
- Albrecht, Carl W. "Arsenic and Old Collections." Ohio Historical Society Local History Notebook. March/April 1993. (Accessed 11/24/08)http://www.ohiohistory.org/resource/oahsm/notebook/marapr1993.html
- Boone and Crockett Club. "26th Big Game Awards Results." (Accessed 11/24/08)http://www.boone-crockett.org/bgRecords/records_26thap_results.asp?area=bgRecords
- Boone and Crocket Club. "Join B&C." (Accessed 11/24/08)http://www.boone-crockett.org/join/associates_overview.asp?area=join
- CITES. "Ivory sales get the go-ahead." Press Releases. 06/02/07. (Accessed 11/24/08)http://www.cites.org/eng/news/press/2007/070602_ivory.shtml
- CITES. "What is CITES?" Discover CITES. (Accessed 11/24/08)http://www.cites.org/eng/disc/what.shtml
- Dorrington, Stewart. "Hunting in South Africa: The New Regulations." CIC. (Accessed 11/24/08)http://www.cic-wildlife.org/index.php?id=263
- Dorrington, Stewart and Butland, Peter. "Trophy Hunting: The Professional Hunter's Dilemma." African Indaba eNewsletter. Vol. 5. No. 3 Special Issue. (Accessed 11/24/08)http://www.africanindaba.co.za/Archive07/AfricanIndabaVol5-3.pdf
- Environmental News Service. "South Africa Curbs Canned Lion Hunting." 02/20/07. (Accessed 11/24/08)http://www.ens-newswire.com/ens/feb2007/2007-02-20-02.asp
- Gunn, Alastair S. "Environmental Ethics and Trophy Hunting." Ethics & the Environment
- Vol. 6 No.1. Indiana University Press. 2001. (Accessed 11/24/08)http://muse.jhu.edu/journals/ethics_and_the_environment/v006/6.1gunn.html
- Lee, Raymond. "Hunting for Trophies." African Indaba eNewsletter. Vol. 5. No. 3 Special Issue. (Accessed 11/24/08)http://www.africanindaba.co.za/Archive07/AfricanIndabaVol5-3.pdf
- Meredith, Don H. "Trophy Hunting." Don H. Meredith Professional Writing Services. 1999. (Accessed 11/24/08)http://www.donmeredith.ca/outdoorsmen/TrophyHunt.html
- Microsoft Encarta Encyclopedia Online. "Taxidermy." (Accessed 11/24/08)http://encarta.msn.com/encyclopedia_761556049/taxidermy.html
- Missoula Valley School of Taxidermy. "Taxidermy School Course Description & Curriculum. (Accessed 11/24/08)http://www.taxidermyschools.com/
- Nelson, Dan. "The Vanishing Hunter, Part 1: Hunting Participation Continues Long-Term Retreat." Delta Waterfowl Magazine. Spring 2008. (Accessed 11/24/08)http://www.deltawaterfowl.org/magazine/2008_01/vanishinghunter.php
- Nilsson, Greta. "Endangered Species Handbook: Persecution and Hunting: Effects of Trophy Hunting on Animals." Animal Welfare Institute. 1983, 2005. (Accessed 11/24/08)http://www.endangeredspecieshandbook.org/persecution_effects.php
- Parker, Ian. "Hunters Shoot Themselves in the Foot." African Indaba eNewsletter. Vol. 5. No. 3 Special Issue. (Accessed 11/24/08)http://www.africanindaba.co.za/Archive07/AfricanIndabaVol5-3.pdf
- Roosevelt, Theodore. "Outdoor Pastimes of an American Hunter." Charles Scribner's Sons. 1908.
- Schramm, Dieter. "Trophy Hunting: How I See It!" African Indaba eNewsletter. Vol. 5. No. 3 Special Issue. (Accessed 11/24/08)http://www.africanindaba.co.za/Archive07/AfricanIndabaVol5-3.pdf
- The Humane Society of the United States. "Trophy Hunting." (Accessed 11/24/08)http://www.hsus.org/wildlife/hunting_old/trophy_hunting/
- Turkey Ridge Hunting and Fishing Sports Club. "Home." (Accessed 11/24/08)http://www.turkeyridgehuntclub.com/index.php
- U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service. "Frequently Asked Questions." Polar Bear Information. (Accessed 11/14/08)http://www.fws.gov/home/feature/2008/polarbear012308/pdf/037257PolarBearQAFINAL.pdf