It's human nature to look for the most successful or easiest way of getting something done. Sure, there are exceptions to any rule -- people who always seek out a challenge. But if there's a tried and true method for making an act easier, or increasing the possibility of success, that method is going to be pretty popular. That gives you a rough idea about why so many hunters use deer baiting.
Deer baiting is strategically placing a pile of food near hunting blinds or clearings in hopes of luring a deer (or bears) into close range. It is seen as useful for precision and accuracy, which are especially challenging in bow hunting. Many states have regulations in place regarding content, seasons and volume, but it gets tricky to regulate between baiting and feeding.
Feeding is a similar practice; it just doesn't yield the same result. People who place feeding piles out usually do so with the intent to attract wildlife onto their property. They do not hunt those animals or allow others to use their pile as bait.
Deer baiting, however, is not without controversy. Fair Chase, which is a set of ethics many hunters live by, states that sportsmen shouldn't have an unfair advantage over the animal. Some people think that baiting might give a hunter an unfair advantage. The lack of a clear answer is what makes deer baiting a controversy, not only in the hunting vs. anti-hunting world, but within the hunting community also.
Deer baiting isn't a simple issue, especially when you begin to consider what other effects deer baiting has outside the world of hunting ethics. The rest of the article will touch on those effects.
Not sure if you're pro deer baiting or against it? Read on to discover two important aspects of the vigorous debate.
Deer Baiting Bans
We all know when it's cold season. Once that first co-worker gets the sniffles, sneezes and headaches, it doesn't take long for his cube-mates to start reaching for the tissues. Before you know it, all of finance is out sick, and HR's looking under the weather. It's tough to avoid catching an illness when it's all around you, and that's the idea behind bans on deer baiting.
When deer congregate together, often repeatedly at a bait pile, they come into close contact. They spread germs and diseases among each other as they lick, touch noses, sneeze, breath, urinate and defecate near the bait pile [source: Sperling]. Once these disease start to spread they can be hard -- and extremely expensive -- to contain.
Baiting can also have lasting impacts on the animal, causing changes in the feeding patterns, reproduction habits, overall behavior and migration [source: Sperling]. If they know there's a bait pile in your back yard, they stop hunting for it themselves and become dependant upon you. And often, the bait doesn't meet the nutritional value that deer need. If the bait is too high in carbohydrates or starches, as is often the case, it can cause damage to the digestion process, sometimes resulting in death.
The reasons behind deer bait bans don't have much to do with ethics, although ethics are important in the overall debate. States step in and ban baiting when they believe it's in the best interest of eliminating the spread of disease among deer. Bans are becoming a widespread trend as 27 states, including Michigan, Minnesota and Wisconsin (popular deer hunting states), already have partial or full bans in place [source: Alabama Wildlife].
Bans haven't shown substantial effect on hunting successes. Bow-hunting triumphs have decreased, but in balance, firearm hunters have found increased success in areas with bans imposed [source: Sharp].
But to every good debate, there are two strong sides. Read on to hear why baiting won't go down without a fight.
Arguments in Favor of Deer Baiting
Many hunters feel that banning deer baiting will change the sport in a big way. Without a doubt, the biggest argument in favor of deer baiting is based on the perception that baiting increases a hunter's success [source: Toso]. If baiting is banned completely, many hunters believe they won't be hitting the buck poles nearly as often, if at all. And as hunting is used as a method for natural resource and species conservation, couldn't ridding the world of it have negative side effects? If hunting success rates go down, then wouldn't that have an adverse effect on future deer populations as competition for food and space increase? That answer isn't clear, but it's a concern for many sportsmen.
Bow hunters feel especially strong about deer baiting. To obtain a clean, quick kill, which is revered in the world of ethical hunting, a bow hunter must hit the target in a specific manner. Without baiting, it would be more difficult to get close enough to ensure the clean kill. Bow hunting is a challenge as is, but if baiting was eliminated from the table, the sport could completely die out [source: Muskegon Chronicle].
Because baiting and feeding are so similar, bans on baiting could mean feeding must end too. Many homeowners would miss this practice.
It's no wonder hunting is such a controversial topic when it's such a diverse sport. But as baiting bans increase in popularity through out state legislatures, perhaps new, more definite information will put an end this aspect of the debate. To learn more about both sides of the deer baiting debate, check out the links on the next page.
Related HowStuffWorks Articles
More Great Links
- Alabama Wildlife Federation. "Don't Take the Bait." (Accessed 12/03/2008)http://www.alabamawildlife.org/baitingbill/default.asp
- Jackson, Alan. "The Pros and Cons of Baiting Deer." Ezine Articles. (Accessed 12/03/2008).http://ezinearticles.com/?The-Pros-And-Cons-Of-Baiting-Deer&id=808471
- Muskegon Chronicle. "Hunters feel strain of deer bait ban." Mlive.com. (Accessed 12/03/2008). http://blog.mlive.com/chronicle/2008/10/for_Sunday_hunters_feel_strain.html
- Sharp, Eric. "Bait ban not likely to reduce deer kill." Detroit Free Press. October 2008. (Accessed 12/03/2008)http://www.freep.com/article/20081016/SPORTS10/810160423/1217/SPORTS
- Sperling, David. L. "The bait debate." Wisconsin Natural Resources magazine. Dec. 1999. (Accessed 12/03/2008).http://www.wnrmag.com/stories/1999/dec99/bait.htm
- Toso, Mark A. "The Effects of Baiting on Deer Hunting in Wisconsin." Michigan United Conservation Clubs. June 2001. (Accessed 12/03/2008).http://www.mucc.org/cwd/baitingeffects.pdf